| 1 | Preacher | 1st Appearance of Jesse Custer; 1st Appearance of The Saint of Killers; 1st Appearance of Cassidy; 1st Appearance of Tulip |
| 1-2 | Preacher | 1st Appearance of Jesse Custer; 1st Appearance of The Saint of Killers; 1st Appearance of Cassidy; 1st Appearance of Tulip; After Watchmen …What’s Next tie-in |
| 1-3 | Preacher | 1st Appearance of Jesse Custer; 1st Appearance of The Saint of Killers; 1st Appearance of Cassidy; 1st Appearance of Tulip; Indicia reads title as Preacher #1 AMC |
| 1-4 | Preacher | 1st Appearance of Jesse Custer; 1st Appearance of The Saint of Killers; 1st Appearance of Cassidy; 1st Appearance of Tulip |
| 1/A | Preacher | 1st Appearance of Jesse Custer; 1st Appearance of The Saint of Killers; 1st Appearance of Cassidy; 1st Appearance of Tulip |
| 1/A-5 | Preacher | 1st Appearance of Jesse Custer; 1st Appearance of The Saint of Killers; 1st Appearance of Cassidy; 1st Appearance of Tulip |
| CP 1 | Preacher | 1st Appearance of Jesse Custer; 1st Appearance of The Saint of Killers; 1st Appearance of Cassidy; 1st Appearance of Tulip |